U-Haul’s biggest competitors are Penske Truck Rental and Budget Truck Rental, the two national rivals U-Haul itself names for both local and one-way moves. Other alternatives include Enterprise Truck Rental and Home Depot for local trips, PODS and U-Pack for container moves, and Public Storage, Extra Space, and CubeSmart in self-storage.
U-Haul is more than a truck company. It also runs over 2,100 self-storage locations, so it competes in two markets at once. Below, I compare 10 rivals using company websites and U-Haul’s own annual report, then explain which one fits which kind of move. It is part of our brand competitors series.
Key Takeaways
- U-Haul’s annual report names Avis Budget Group (Budget Truck) and Penske as its main national rivals.
- U-Haul has over 25,000 locations, far more than Penske’s 2,000-plus.
- Penske offers unlimited mileage on one-way truck rentals.
- Enterprise, Home Depot, and Ryder do not offer one-way rentals for personal moves.
- U-Haul’s revenue rose 3.6% to $6.04 billion in fiscal 2026, but its net earnings fell to $83.1 million.
U-Haul Competitors at a Glance
| Competitor | Type | One-way moves | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Penske | Truck rental | Yes, unlimited mileage | Long-distance moves |
| Budget Truck Rental | Truck rental | Yes | One-way moves, discounts |
| Enterprise Truck Rental | Truck rental | No (limited exceptions) | Local moves |
| Home Depot | Truck rental | No | Short local hauls |
| Turo, Lugg, GoShare | In-town options | Varies | Small local jobs |
| PODS | Moving containers | Yes | Loading at your own pace |
| U-Pack | Moving containers | Yes | Long-distance, someone else drives |
| Public Storage, Extra Space, CubeSmart | Self-storage | Not applicable | Storage only |
| Ryder | Commercial truck rental | No | Businesses only |
Who Is U-Haul’s Biggest Competitor?
Penske and Budget are U-Haul’s biggest competitors. In its fiscal 2026 annual report, U-Haul says its “major national competitors in both the in-town and one-way moving equipment rental market include Avis Budget Group, Inc. and Penske Truck Leasing.” Avis Budget Group owns Budget Truck Rental.
For local moves, U-Haul also lists Enterprise Truck Rental, Turo, Lugg, and GoShare. In self-storage, it names Public Storage, CubeSmart, and Extra Space Storage as its largest rivals, according to its 10-K filing.
Why does U-Haul stay ahead? For me, it is the network. U-Haul has over 2,400 company-run stores and over 23,000 independent dealers, which is why its trucks are almost everywhere. That reach is hard for any rival to copy, a classic competitive advantage.
U-Haul vs. Its Top Truck Rental Rivals
| Company | Truck sizes | One-way | Locations |
|---|---|---|---|
| U-Haul | Pickup, cargo van, 10′, 15′, 20′, 26′, 29′ | Yes | Over 25,000 |
| Penske | Cargo van, 12′, 16′, 22′, 26′ | Yes (trucks only), unlimited miles | Over 2,000 |
| Budget | Cargo van, 12′, 16′, 26′ | Yes | Not stated on site |
| Enterprise | Trucks and vans | No, with limited exceptions | Not stated on site |
| Home Depot | F-250 pickup, cargo van, 14′ box truck | No | Home Depot stores |
Sources: company websites; Home Depot details from This Old House (June 2026).
1. Penske Truck Rental
Penske is U-Haul’s closest rival for long-distance moves. When you return a Penske truck to a different location, its 12-, 16-, 22-, and 26-foot trucks come with unlimited mileage, according to Penske’s website. Its cargo van is round-trip only.
Penske also offers 12% off for AAA members and 15% off for military customers with a promo code, plus a student discount. For me, unlimited mileage is Penske’s strongest selling point against U-Haul on long trips, where per-mile charges can add up. Discounts like these are a form of customer loyalty program aimed at specific groups.
2. Budget Truck Rental
Budget Truck is owned by Avis Budget Group, which U-Haul names as a major national competitor. Budget rents a cargo van and 12-, 16-, and 26-foot trucks. Its 26-foot truck carries up to 10,000 pounds, or about 500 medium boxes, according to Budget’s website.
Budget offers one-way rentals and has discount programs for military members, AARP members, and students. In HireAHelper’s 2026 price data, Budget had the lowest typical cost of the truck companies it tracked, for both local and long-distance moves.
3. Enterprise Truck Rental
Enterprise competes with U-Haul on local moves only. “With limited exceptions, one-way truck or van rentals aren’t permitted,” Enterprise says in its rental FAQ. Trucks must go back to the location where you picked them up.
Is Enterprise cheaper than U-Haul? It depends on distance. In a May 2026 quote published on U-Haul’s own site, a 15-foot truck for three days cost $97.49 plus $0.99 per mile at U-Haul and $239.33 plus $0.18 per mile at Enterprise. Since U-Haul ran the comparison, treat it with care, but it shows how per-mile rates can flip the answer on longer trips.
4. Home Depot Truck Rental
Home Depot rents F-250 pickup trucks, cargo vans, and 14-foot box trucks for short local jobs. Its Load ‘N Go rate for the F-250 flatbed and cargo van is $19, according to This Old House. Home Depot does not offer one-way rentals.
For me, Home Depot competes with U-Haul’s pickups and vans, not its big moving trucks. It is a good fit for carrying a sofa home, not for moving a whole house.
5. Turo, Lugg, and GoShare
U-Haul’s annual report names Turo, Lugg, and GoShare among its in-town competitors, alongside Enterprise. For me, their inclusion shows that U-Haul sees competition not only from other rental fleets but also from newer ways of getting a truck or a hand for a small local job.
6. PODS
PODS is a container company. It began as a portable storage company in 1998 and offers 8-foot and 16-foot containers, according to PODS. It drops a container at your home, you load it at your own pace, and PODS stores it or delivers it to your new home. PODS says it has more than 240 storage centers.
Why is PODS a U-Haul alternative? For people who do not want to drive a large truck, a container removes that job entirely. That is a different kind of competition from Penske or Budget.
7. U-Pack
U-Pack ships your belongings in a ReloCube, a weatherproof metal container that fits in a single parking space. You load and lock it, and U-Pack moves it. Its rates include the driver and fuel, and every ReloCube move comes with 30 days of free storage, according to U-Pack.
For me, U-Pack sits between a rental truck and a full-service mover. You still pack and load, but you never drive.
8. Public Storage, Extra Space, and CubeSmart
U-Haul is also a major self-storage company. It had 2,113 self-storage locations and 99.0 million square feet of storage space at the end of fiscal 2026, according to its 10-K. In self-storage, U-Haul names Public Storage, CubeSmart, and Extra Space Storage as its largest competitors.
Why does storage matter? Self-storage revenue rose 8.3% to $972.4 million in fiscal 2026, much faster than truck rental revenue. For me, this is U-Haul’s smartest expansion strategy: a customer who rents a truck may also need storage, and U-Haul can sell both.
9. Ryder
Ryder is a well-known truck name, and crossword solvers list “Ryder” as the top answer to the “U-Haul competitor” clue. But Ryder does not serve home movers. Its website says “Ryder rents trucks only for commercial purposes” and that it “does not accept personal or one-way rentals.”
So Ryder competes with U-Haul only for business customers, not for families moving house. Learn how companies compete for different customer groups in our guide to business competition.
10. Full-Service Movers
The last alternative is not renting anything at all. Full-service moving companies pack, load, drive, and unload for you. For me, they compete with U-Haul on convenience, not price: the do-it-yourself model is U-Haul’s core business, and every family that hires movers is a rental U-Haul does not get.
How Is U-Haul Doing Against Its Competitors?
U-Haul is still growing, but profit came under pressure in fiscal 2026, which ended March 31, 2026:
| Measure | FY2026 | FY2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Total revenue | $6.04 billion | $5.83 billion |
| Truck and trailer rental revenue | $3.81 billion | $3.73 billion |
| Self-storage revenue | $972.4 million | $897.9 million |
| Net earnings | $83.1 million | $367.1 million |
Source: U-Haul Holding Company fiscal 2026 results.
The company lost $127.8 million in its fourth quarter. “This is the second time in recent years we have had a real loss in this quarter,” said Joe Shoen. U-Haul’s fleet stood at about 204,800 trucks and 136,600 trailers.
What is U-Haul doing about it? In May 2026, U-Haul launched a 29-foot “Easy Mover” truck, its first project with Peterbilt. It holds 2,057 cubic feet and starts at $49.95 for in-town rentals, the same base rate as its 26-foot truck in most markets. It launched first in Greater Los Angeles and Philadelphia. For me, this is how a market leader defends its position: give customers a bigger option rivals do not offer, at no extra base price.
Which U-Haul Alternative Should You Choose?
| Your move | Best option | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Long-distance, driving yourself | Penske or Budget | One-way rentals; Penske adds unlimited mileage |
| Local, one day | U-Haul, Enterprise, or Home Depot | Round-trip rentals for short jobs |
| You do not want to drive a truck | PODS or U-Pack | They move the container for you |
| You need storage too | U-Haul or a self-storage company | U-Haul combines both |
| Large house | U-Haul 29-foot or a 26-foot from any rival | Largest rental trucks |
What size truck do you need? Before you compare prices, check the size. Here is a free moving truck size calculator estimates the cubic feet and weight of your move and shows the smallest U-Haul, Penske, or Budget truck that fits.
What is cheaper than U-Haul? HireAHelper publishes typical (median) costs for a 3-bedroom move, based on rentals booked by its customers in 2026:
| Option | Local (25 miles) | 1,400 miles | 2,400 miles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | $79.20 | $1,180.89 | $1,789.41 |
| Enterprise | $92.40 | $1,377.70 | $2,087.65 |
| Penske | $148.50 | $2,214.17 | $3,355.14 |
| U-Haul | $160.00 | $1,945.84 | $2,948.55 |
| Moving containers | $582.19 | $2,719.37 | $4,661.78 |
| Full-service movers | $1,480.00 | $6,005.00 | $9,255.00 |
Source: HireAHelper Rental Truck Price Database, 2026. HireAHelper does not publish its sample size, so treat these as a guide.
In this data, Budget came out cheapest at every distance, and Penske cost more than U-Haul on long moves despite unlimited mileage. For me, the lesson is to compare quotes from at least three companies for the same truck size and dates, because your city and timing can change the order.
Bottom Line
For me, U-Haul’s real advantage is not price but reach: over 25,000 locations, the largest truck lineup, and a growing storage business. Penske and Budget are its true rivals for one-way moves, while PODS and U-Pack win customers who would rather not drive. U-Haul’s weaker 2026 profit shows the pressure is real, and its 29-foot truck and storage push are how it plans to keep its lead.
Frequently Asked Questions
-Usually not. HireAHelper’s 2026 data for a 2-bedroom move shows U-Haul cheaper locally and cross-country, though results vary by move size. We compare prices, sizes, and fees in
The most common answer is “Ryder,” a well-known truck rental name. Ryder rents trucks only to businesses and does not accept personal or one-way rentals, so it does not compete with U-Haul for home moves.
U-Haul’s largest rental truck is the 29-foot “Easy Mover,” launched in May 2026 with Peterbilt. It holds 2,057 cubic feet and carries up to 11,939 pounds. It was first offered in Greater Los Angeles and Philadelphia.
Generally no. Enterprise says that, with limited exceptions, one-way truck or van rentals are not permitted, and trucks must be returned to the original location. For one-way moves, U-Haul, Penske, and Budget are the main options.
U-Haul says it has over 25,000 locations. Its annual report counts over 2,400 company-operated moving stores and over 23,000 independent dealers across the US and Canada, plus 2,113 self-storage locations.

